Saturday, May 29, 2010

The page that made a fan out of a manatee!

In [1972] I had just begun collecting comics. I'd always enjoyed reading them, and had been envious of the tall stacks in the homes of some friends. But the summer [of XXX], a bunkmate at camp had brought with him the latest issues of several Marvel series. Spider-Man [describe storyline] (around issues XXX-XXX or so), and in Captain America a character claiming to be the titular hero was going around beating up black people and those he perceived as "commies."

When I got home I just had to know how these stories turned out, especially the latter one. It didn't hurt matters (or maybe I should say didn't help) that I'd just transferred, reluctantly, to a new school, a subway ride away from my neighborhood, where I knew next to nobody. So after my lonely ride home, I began haunting a local newsstand near where I emerged from the subway, waiting to find the next issues of Cap and Spidey - which I eventually got. But soon my attention was drawn to other titles on the racks. On one cover, a rifle-bearing, humanoid rat threatened a blond-haired boy in cut-off blue jeans (Kamandi #2). On another, police fired guns at a fierce-looking monster thrashing his way out of a net (Werewolf by Night #X). On a third, a strange green creature rose, covered in brown leaves, from a marsh, while in the background lurked a creature with demonically pointed ears (another werewolf, from Swamp Thing #2). I grabbed them all up.

One day a book appeared with an especially intriguing cover. Batman - looking very different from the Adam West portrayal I'd loved not that many years before - stood between a row of police and the Joker (far slenderer and more threatening than Cesar Romero), angrily saying, "Stay back! Nobody lays a hand on my partner while I'm around!" There was no doubt that the Joker was still a bad guy - on a wall was a "Wanted" poster with his face. What was Batman doing protecting his arch-enemy?

It was Brave & Bold #111, written by Bob Haney and drawn by Jim Aparo. I gave the man my [12 cents] and went home to read it. I won't belabor the storyline, except to say that the Joker engaged Batman to clear him of a mass murder he didn't commit. I enjoyed it quite a bit. (It came as a bit of a shock to me to see XXX.)

I doubt I noticed at the time, but one page showed such apt visual storytelling that it became my gold standard for the craft. Nothing much happened, really: Batman showed up at an abandoned canal lock where the Joker had asked him to meet. There he found only a playing card - a Joker, naturally - picked it up, and suddenly became aware of XXX. There was no fistfight, no argument, not even two characters. But this page just worked.

Here it is:


This page could have been drawn so many ways, but look at how Aparo handles it.

Change of scale.

There are very few words, yet the eye flows XXX and sees everything that needs to be seen. (Later I got into the practice of looking at comic book pages before reading the words, to see how well I could understand what was going on from the pictures alone. I don't think this is the only way to judge a comic book page - words do matter - but it's not something to be ignored.)

If I were teaching comic book storytelling, I'd use this page.

I should add that this comic also made me a fan of Jim Aparo. A journeyman artist. He's an underappreciated artist, IMO, and it's true that his later work lost some of the energy and rich, Caniff-ian inking